Monthly Archives: September 2018

Weill/Brecht 2: Yes, “Mahagonny” Is An Opera

ANNOUNCEMENT NO. 1: Last reminder: Next Friday, Sept. 28, I will be appearing in the Marc Scorca Auditorium at Opera America, 330 Seventh Ave., NYC, to speak and read from my book, “Opera as Opera,” converse about related subjects with Mr. Scorca, and conduct some Q & A. There will be books for sale (sorry, can’t do credit cards), and these will be the only books available for a few weeks, because . . .

ANNOUNCEMENT NO. 2: The initial print run of “Opera as Opera” is SOLD OUT! The pace of sales was much faster than projected. A second printing is scheduled , but owing to a very heavy schedule at the printer’s, books will not be ready to ship till around November 1. We will of course post the exact shipping date as soon as it’s firm. You can still pre-order for this second printing, and be sure of a copy being reserved for you.

˜ ˜ ˜ 

In my last post, I wrote about some of the principles of Epic Theatre, transmitted to us  principally via the plays of Bertolt Brecht and by the copious theoretical literature about them  by the author himself and by followers, critics, and scholars. Being engaged here with opera, I was interested primarily in the way that some of these principles, especially that of a Separation of Elements, continue to exercise influence on that artform, and in the strange fact that this influence has been more on the production of operas quite incompatible with those principles than in the creation of new operas of Epic character. And I noted that Brecht published his formulation in its most direct and succinct form in relation not to one of his plays, but to the opera The Rise and Fall of the City of Mahagonny, which he and composer Kurt Weill premiered in 1930. (I)

Since Brecht was the most important German playwright of his time and a highly regarded poet as well, and since (like Stanislavski, but unlike, say, Reinhardt or even Meyerhold) he wrote out at length his theories on theatre, acting, and music, his ideas have always been before us, and in definitive form. But he was not the only artist writing on the new directions for theatre and opera (and, eventually, on Mahagonny itself) in the aesthetic maelstrom of Weimar Germany. Weill was no mean essayist in his own right, and between 1925 (before his first meeting with Brecht) and 1929 he turned out over a hundred articles for Der Deutsche Rundfunk (the magazine of the then-new German broadcasting system) and other journals. These, however, were never gathered in book form, and simply dropped from sight after the ascension of the Nazis. Since the 1950s, musicologists and other scholars have worked to restore to Weill his independence of thought and to correct the common impression that in the Weill/Brecht collaboration, Brecht did everything but write down the notes. (An overview of Weill’s musical thinking at this time, and translations of some of his articles, can be found in Kim Kowalke’s Kurt Weill in Europe.) With respect to Mahagonny: as Brecht himself rather glumly concluded, it’s an opera, and, brilliant and convention-defying as Brecht’s libretto for it is, in an opera the music is the final determinant of viability.

Footnotes

Footnotes
I Here I must enter a correction to my last article: in addition to the productions I listed there, there were mountings of the opera in several other German opera houses, as well as in Prague and Vienna, before the Nazi ban took effect in 1933. Political disturbances, some turning violent, were attendant on most of them, and other projected productions were cancelled in advance.

A Weill/Brecht Refresher

REMINDER: Friday, Sept. 28, at 7:30 in the Marc Scorca Auditorium of Opera America, 330 Seventh Avenue, New York City, I’ll be reading from “Opera as Opera,” conversing with Marc Scorca himself about aspects of the book and the operatic scene, and following with a Q & A session. I hope to see many New York area readers and devotees then!

 In the mid-1950s, I worked for a couple of years as a secretary (or “male secretary,” as it was customarily named) in the travel trade, for Thomas Cook & Son. Those were the twilight years of the “Cook’s Tour” company as the more or less royally designated booker for the imperium on which the sun never set. The office atmosphere was neo-Dickensian, with pay scale to match, and my position next-to-bottom rung. But there were some nice end-of-week parties, at which the Basic Black dresses, bow ties, seersucker suits and ice-cream jackets created a sort of penniless glamour—or, for reasons about to become clear, what I might call Threepenny Glamour.

At these parties, music was always playing—monophonic LPs, or—in some instances still—78s, on whatever console or low-hi-fi component rig the evening’s host/ess could afford. This being a travel-bum crowd, the repertoire was predominantly from across the pond. Charles Trenet,  Germaine Montero, and Bea Lillie were big. But more often than not, prime playing time was given to Noel Coward (The Las Vegas Album) and Lotte Lenya (the Berlin Theatre Songs album). They were not taken as mere background music (there was Mantovani for that). Folks stopped chatting, gathered round, and followed. They knew the words, they knew the tunes. Newcomers were initiated, and soon joined in the unison choruses at the payoff lines of “In a Bar on the Piccola Marina,” “I’ll Follow My Secret Heart,” “Mad Dogs and Englishmen,” or of “Surabaya Johnny,” the “Alabama Song,” or “Pirate Jenny.” Coward had for some years been in somewhat the same condition as the Empire itself, but was now revived for one more go-round by his brilliant nightclub appearances. Lenya carried the guidon for a culture that actually bore the same time stamp as Coward’s, but was to us by way of discovery, old/new, rebellious/decadent. Coward singing Coward and Lenya singing Weill may seem a very odd pairing. But they had in common inimitable personalities, a mastery of cabaret craft, and a tone of world-weariness that suggested past excitements now faded, old wisdoms that were slipping away.

One of the three distinct Weills, Weill the Third, had already been known to us. That was the Weill of the American musicals and the hit songs they birthed (“September Song,” “Speak Low,” and others); of Down in the Valley, the brief American-style Schuloper that wedded an operatic parable to the folk-music movement of the time; and of Street Scene, Weill’s operatic adaptation of Elmer Rice’s play, with lyrics by Langston Hughes, that ran on Broadway for 148 performances. But now Lenya, the composer’s widow, carried the torch for Weill the Second, first via the hit production of The Threepenny Opera at the Theatre de Lys and its cast album, then with the above-noted LP, and then, at least for us in New York, through a long series of performance events: I recall a Weill evening at the Lewisohn Stadium concerts, with Threepenny in its Blitzstein translation; a full-blown concert performance in German at Carnegie Hall that brought us Ludwig Donath and Polyna Stoska as the Peachums(I); and The Seven Deadly Sins at the New York City Ballet, with Balanchine the choreographer, as he had been at the work’s premiere (Paris, 1933). The New York City Opera staged Threepenny, in German, rather ponderously and in too large a theatre, with Martha Schlamme as Jenny and Kurt Kasznar as Macheath. And along the way, there were the superb complete original-language recordings on Columbia (Philips) of Die Dreigroschenoper and a work previously unknown to most of us except through one of its numbers, the aforementioned “Alabama Song”—Der Aufstieg und Fall der Stadt Mahagonny (“The Rise and Fall of the City of Mahagonny”). All this was very much driven by the stardom of Lenya, and enabled by the presence of the same emigré generation that also formed a core audience for the big-business years of Lieder singing here.

Footnotes

Footnotes
I Donath, one of the many Austrian and German stage actors of the time who had managed the adaptation to the  American film and stage industries, also worked with the Metropolitan’s young singers on their acting. “I insist,” he said to me during an interview, “that singers are not stupid! It’s only their actions that make them appear so!” Stoska, the original Anna Maurrant of the operatic Street Scene, created something of a sensation as The Composer in the New York City Opera’s Ariadne auf Naxos (the work’s New York premiere) and then had a couple of seasons at the Met, where her roles included Donna Elvira and Elsa. In the Threepenny performance a decade later, she re- emerged in deep-mezzo form and sang a convincing Mrs. Peachum.