Though I’d had major reservations about Proving Up, I’d heard in it brief segments of a folksy idiom I thought could be appropriate for this very American story. There was also evidence of attraction to a surreal sub-or-superhuman plane of existence in the characters of two sisters who are apparently dead yet continue to comment on developments, and in that of The Sodbuster, a mysterious figure who appears late in the opera and seems to have an omniscient knowledge of all that has happened—all potentially Bardo-esque. No such luck. Lincoln was very hard to endure, harder than any of the other contemporary pieces I’ve seen at the Met over the past decade. The command of compositional materials I’d ascribed to Mazzoli held up with respect to the deployment of her orchestral forces. But to what end? I can’t describe that better than I did in my Proving Up review: her orchestra (here magnified to full big-opera strength) “shrieks, pounds, glisses, and moans,” the gestures often “sounding more like serial sound effects than they do like music,” and “creating an assaultive atmosphere of sweaty drama that remains just that—a generalized atmosphere.” Atmosphere, in fact, is something Mazzoli is shooting for. In a program booklet conversation, she speaks of wanting to evoke the “magical, unrealistic space” she believes Saunders has created, and that she wanted to “capture that world and create that sense of mystery.” In one sequence, I thought, she succeeded in some of that. Late in Act 1, a complement of angels descends into The Bardo in the hope of moving things along, since those who linger may find themselves trapped in permanently unpleasant circumstances. In this scene, the fusion of pit and stage—music that, if not exactly beautiful, was at least lyrically inviting, bonded with a visually appealing sequence—did lend us some eight or ten minutes of atmospheric surcease. But it was a lonely exception.
As to the vocal writing, Mazzoli and Vavrek set themselves a tough task. In Proving Up, Vavrek, working largely from scratch, had shown some poetic inclinations. Here, he is for the most part transcribing directly from Saunders’ text, heavily redacted so as to exclude the passages of commentary from the references and bring in the rest at theatrically tolerable length. Saunders’ dialogue has its own rhythms, its own expressive manners; it seldom suggests lyrical treatment or a need for completion through singing. On the page, more eloquence, more personality, often comes from the speeches of the cited sources than from the enactors of the narrative—but as noted, they are, with that single exception, deleted from the opera. From the exchanges among Vollman, Blevins, and The Reverend, with which we spend much time in both novel and opera, we can extract information, but little inflectional variety or distinctiveness of character. It’s of a sort that one can imagine spoken by verbally gifted actors in a play or movie, or that Mozart or Rossini might have set as rapid-fire recitative to be performed with dash, as repartee, and with the orchestra reduced to a strictly complementary position to leave the singers in charge and ensure the clarity of the words. That, though, is not Mazzoli’s way.
