“Lincoln in the Bardo” at the Met.

For the rest: it was hard to get much of a line on Ryan McKinny (Vollman) and Jonah Hoskins (Bevins). They sang at length and with competence for their assignments, but their music was so nondescript as to give them little opportunity to register. McKinny, listed as a bass-baritone though sounding more like a medium-weight baritone, made most of his impression by way of a cartoonishly long, erect penis he was obliged to sport in the opening scene. (Vollman’s misfortune was to have been struck dead by a falling beam at the moment of truth on his wedding night—there are references in the book to his “swollen member.”) This appendage required the help of a puppeteer to maintain and then tuck away (hard to show detumescence in real time, I guess), and elicited scattered guffaws from the audience. As Blevins, Hoskins showed what he could of a voice that falls somewhere between a tenor of the lyric and character categories. Of his setting, Mazzoli explains that Blevins is “this queer seventeen-year-old who committed suicide . . . [he’s] in this excited, anxious state all the time, so he’s constantly singing these crazy ornaments” (like those queer, anxious, suicidal guys Almaviva, Ottavio, et al.). But the ornaments are neither crazy nor interesting. They’re just generic signifiers of selected affects. Then we had Stephanie Blythe and Craig Colclough as Eddie and Betsy Baron, who in the novel are a lower-class, foul-mouthed couple who gleefully recall their misadventures and neglectful parenting. Blythe fielded tattered remnants of her once-formidable mezzo in the service of comic “characterization,” while Colclough, another bass-baritone, made little headway vis à vis the spectacle. I couldn’t figure out why these two had been dragged into the opera. Soprano Viviana Goodwin made a nice impression as Litzie, a slave rendered mute by sexual trauma, who briefly recovers her voice in The Bardo before moving on. From all the singers of these subsidiary roles, the tenor Joshua Blue stood out as the former slave Thomas Havens, not because he is necessarily more talented than the others (though he did well with his material), but because he occupied a more defined place in the narrative, and was allowed to take stage and sing to us for a while to some of the score’s better music. Finally: I am often struck by my impression that the Met orchestra digs into contemporary scores with greater willingness than they do in the canonical repertoire, and that was the case here. Probably it’s mostly the challenge of getting on top of new music. But there’s also the sobering possibility that they prefer this stuff to the masterworks, and that no conductor refreshes their engagement with them.

My only previous experience with Blain-Cruz, the director, had been her production of Thornton Wilder’s The Skin of Our teeth at the Beaumont. There, she submerged an inrteresting, problematic play that calls for a childlike simplicity and clarity of presentation in a cascade of flashy effects. Here, some of the same inclinations were evident in the appeal for cheap laughs (the “swollen member”) and circus thrills (Willie’s whizzing ascension in a burst of fireworks, to a little fit of applause), and in the production’s eager participation in the contemporary eye-over-ear shift in opera’s sensory reception. (I)But I sympathized with the problem of representing by theatrical means both the otherworldiness the piece was trying to capture (I thought of Britten’s indication of place for the Peter Quint/Miss Jessel scene in the aforementioned Turn of the Screw—”Nowhere.”) and the behavioral jumpiness of the character action. The Bardo is a place where “. . . things can shift very quickly. Nothing is ever clearly one thing or another,” says Mazzoli, and we could even posit that the jittery busyness onstage was a reflection of the incessant nervousness in the music—an integration of elements! Nor could the production be censured as auteurial reinterpretation, since it’s an original, undertaken with the full advice and consent of composer, librettist, and source author. Rather, the problem seems to me inherent in the whole idea to begin with. What made these talented people think that Saunders’ vision, reliant on the imagination of each reader’s unique realization of a realm of impossibilities, would work on the stage, or that his manners of speech would translate into singing eloquence ? The composer notes that “So much of this story meditates on death and dying,” while Saunders says: “Love and grief are two sides of the same coin. For me, the story is not so much about death as it is about love”—a quite difference of emphasis. Surely parents’ grief over the loss of a child (Abe and Mary Lincoln endured that three times, twice in quite quick succession) should be deeply moving, as should Abe’s love of his child, and the child’s transfiguration in death. But where is either the grief or the love in Mazzoli’s music? Lost in an endless, feverish chatter that’s “not ever clearly one thing or another,” and in a few moments of atmosphere.

Footnotes

Footnotes
↑I I thought the physical production—set: Adam Rigg, a good look, as well accommodated to the actiion as could be expected, and costumes: Montana Levi Blanco, evocative—served well.