“Lincoln in the Bardo” at the Met.

On October 19, the Metropolitan Opera presented the world premiere of Lincoln in the Bardo, an opera by Missy Mazzoli with libretto by Royce Vavrek, based on the best-selling, prize-winning novel of that name by George Saunders. It was directed by Lileana Blain-Cruz and conducted by Yannick Nézet-Séguin, with Peter Mattei and Christine Goerke in leading roles. I saw the sixth performance, on November 3rd.

As longtime readers may recall, my lengthy experience of time spent with new operas (the majority of them American) has led me to limit my exposure to one per season for most of the duration of this series. And after surveying five recent examples on recordings (see A New American Rep?, 4/4/25), I silently vowed to reduce that to zero, pending the arrival of some solidly established recent work not yet seen here. Lincoln is not that. But the high expectations aroused by the collaboration among these creators (including Saunders himself, who was involved in the early stages of the process) led me to make an exception for Lincoln. And I was not without hope. A previous opera by Mazzoli and Vavrek, Proving Up, was among the five in that survey, and although I did not much care for it, I felt that among that quintet of composers, Mazzoli was the one most completely in charge of her compositional materials. She might, I thought, respond to a commission from the Met with something interesting.

As always with operas old or new that are unknown to me, I deemed acquaintance with the source a necessary part of my performance prep. So I turned to the novel. Its action occurs in the days immediately after the death of Abraham Lincoln’s 11-year-old son Willie, in 1862, with the Civil War less than a full year underway,(I) and is set in The Bardo, an imagined realm where souls tarry before being assigned to their eternal dwelling places. There, Willie encounters many other residents of the The Bardo, among whom much discussion of their lives’ determining events and possible final destinations takes place. Lincoln, in his grief, visits his son’s body several times in the graveyard. On the last of these visits, graveyard and Bardo, father and son, are fused, and Willie in effect grants his father release from his grief. Lincoln returns with resolve to his great tasks, and Willie is soon transported to his heavenly abode.

I started the novel with great anticipation, but soon ran aground. Its narrative technique is certainly ingenious. Dialogue and monologue move back and forth among The Bardo’s denizens, and each speech is tagged with a footnoted reference to its source. These are sometimes taken from the historical record, at other times invented, so that all, authentic or not, become parts of the fictional narrative. In the opening pages and for many thereafter, the dialogue is between two characters called Hans Vollman and Roger Bevins iii, soon joined by Willie and The Reverend Everly Thomas, then by other characters with fragments of their backstories and by Lincoln himself, on the first of his visits. By page 101, eight more characters have been introduced, each with some slow-reveal plaint or commentary, interspersed with stretches of quotes from the real-or-not references that cast scholarly perspective on the proceedings.(II) It was at this point that I laid the book aside. I felt myself treading water with bantering characters that did not engage me, holding forth in well- or ill-mannered versions of a reconstructed 1860s Speak. And I was becoming increasingly annoyed at being reminded, sometimes several times on a page, of how technically inventive it all was. Finally, I was starting to sense that the author was not actually trying to engage me with these characters in any empathetic way, but to hold them up to a kind of clinical inspection—a feeling reinforced by my reading of a short story by Saunders, Appeasement, Ohio, which happened to be running in The New Yorker and with which, paragraph for paragraph, I had an even more difficult time than I was having with Lincoln. Perhaps, I thought, it was best to accept that I was reading a much-admired book by a very talented author whose wavelength I was simply not on. Perhaps it was best to just wait and see if Mazzoli’s music could transform the novel into something operatically compelling; I could always return to the book afterward. And that is what I did.

Footnotes

Footnotes
↑I Three months to the day after Willie’s death, Lincoln signed into law the Homestead Act, which opened Nebraska and several other states to land-grant settlement, partly in order to ensure that they not fall into the pro-slavery Confederacy. That sets the scene for Proving Up—an odd connection, coincidental or not, between the two operas.
↑II A total of 166 “characters” are ascribed to the book by the creators. This has to include, though, all the cited sources, and while some of those are  sufficiently developed to assume character status in the novel, with one exception they don’t become actors in the operatic narrative, or appear onstage. The Met program lists thirty onstage solo performers, though half of them are pantomimic figures who do not sing. My familiarity with the novel notwithstanding, I found myself consulting the surtitles (I never do that) just to confirm what was being sung, in my own language, and who might be singing it.