In an opera, the text’s setting is perforce conveyed by the singing and the physical action. Three of the principals registered to recognizably operatic effect: Peter Mattei (Lincoln), Christine Goerke (The Reverend Everly Thomas), and Janai Brugger (Mrs. Francis Hodge). Mattei’s voice—a high, heady baritone, ample and warm—struck me as a strange choice for the deep bass that I would associate with the real-life Lincoln. But it is adaptable to the tender side of the part’s expressive range, which sounded written with his voice in mind, and he sustained the supple, altitudinous line of his most important music (did I hear a Bb/A# in there?) with ease, suggesting a fine Pelléas of the Singher/Uppman baritone sort. He sings English well, though without the rugged rhetorical tone an imaginative American might bring to the music. Goerke was the beneficiary of a gender switcheroo. The Reverend of the novel is indubitably male, but in the opera he’s a she, set for the range and format of a dramatic mezzo. That raises another real-life plausibility question, and seems merely a cover for yet another concession to contemporary social correctness preferences. But the composer’s defense would be impregnable: this is an unreal life, so “all is allowed me now,” to quote the text in another connection. Goerke’s large, full-timbred soprano, steadier at this stage than I had foreseen, was a good fit for the writing, and she sang well. Finally, it was a pleasure to hear Brugger’s sweet, light lyric soprano sailing out from her suspended perch with some of the score’s most sympathetic vocal writing, though in too short a part to offer extended relief from the orchestral battering.
Among the other roles, the most important emotionally, though not in length, is that of Willie, scored for boy soprano. At my performance (there was an alternate), Michael Hurst took the part. He’s an extremely talented young man. Musically, he was spot on with cues and intonation. Physically, he performed with energy and intent. And his voice, unmiked, carried well. Its quality, however, was not attractive (penetrating but plain—many a church choir boasts a boy soprano with prettier tone). So, this being an opera, the overall effect was not very pleasurable. It’s a lot to ask of so young a performer, which is why it is asked so seldom. Miles, in Britten’s The Turn of the Screw, is the only boy soprano role I can recall of comparable length and centrality (with a quick nod to Yniold in Pelléas). But Turn of the Screw is more chamber-ish in its distributions, and its composer, steeped in the English boy soprano/falsettist church traditions, was far more accomplished in setting for the voice. And speaking of falsettists, we had one of the most prominent, Anthony Roth Costanzo, as Miss Elise Traynor, in another sex swap. Poor Elise has died at fourteen and, having failed to move on from The Bardo, is now eternally trapped therein, lashed to a fence by the tendrils that begin to entwine the loiterers, changing shape in a sort of recursive loop and enduring the stares of passing men. Costanzo twisted his voice into several distorted modes, some suggestive of the “Extended Voice” scam (“a lot of wild vocal techniques,” says Mazzoli) while several of the pantomimists who represented the tendrils and other phenomena worked away at her billowing skirt and the shape-shifting changes. It was an embarrassing interlude.
