After the performance, we met another couple, old friends, for a late bite. All four of us had been stunned by the emptiness of work and production, and of course some of our discussion concerned that and our hypothesized reasons for it. But we soon found ourselves talking about something else, too. This show is a hit. Its nine performances have been packed, and although we know that many of the tickets have not been sold at full price, or any price at all, that’s still remarkable under the prevailing conditions.(I) And we wondered, why? At least at this performance, the audience, quite different in feel than the one for the season-opening Macbeth though certainly overlapping with it, clearly reacted more to visual cues than to musical or vocal ones. It responded to the bows and smiles of the curtain call in exact proportion to the relative importance of the performers, with the extra boost for the orchestra and its conductor and for the production team that has become de rigeur at all Met performances. In other words: with an utterly indiscriminate ritual enthusiasm. Speaking of them as a group (thus eliminating abstainers in unknown number), they appeared to have enjoyed it in some way. Again we wondered, how? In what way? Had they just been sold a bill of goods by the Met’s social media campaign? Were they awed by the house, by the size of the stage and the assembled forces, or by the company’s tech capabilities, which are beyond those of any other live performance enterprise? Had they been truly moved or excited, or were they only behaving as if so, out of perceived obligation?
That’s a puzzle, parts of whose answer must lie with the above suggestions in some combination for each individual. But with a few days’ perspective, another thought occurred to me. I don’t think it can have been a conscious part of Saunders’ thinking (his book had apparently been in gestation for twenty years before he started writing it), and to judge from everything disclosed wouldn’t seem to have been in the minds of the opera’s creators or interpreters, either. It’s this: we are all in a Bardo, here and now, a sort of frantic hangout or Eternal Temporary (the German sociologist Helmut Rosa calls it a Frenetic Standstill—that’s good), awaiting transition to a final destination we fantasize as either a Paradise or a Hades, and meanwhile struggling to avoid the tendrils of lost history, lost aspiration, which threaten to keep us scrambling and writhing in an endless Now. No more than with the creators do I believe this message is announcing itself to the receptors with any immediate clarity. But possibly, in a way that sometimes happens with art, some folks, uninitiated into opera and unconcerned with its customary standards of evaluation, recognize an undefined something in what they’re seeing and hearing. The something might someday come to the surface and identify itself. If so, that would be a positive. It would give Lincoln in the Bardo a reason for being.
˜ ˜ ˜
NEXT TIME: My next engagement with the Met is with Puccini’s La fanciulla del West, in a new production that will mark the company debut of a soprano highly regarded in Europe, Vida Mikneviciute. That will not happen before the turn of the year, and my work on another project may keep me occupied in the meantime. Other subjects I have in mind, though, are a long-projected article on opera singers singing Lieder (I’m hoping for a stronger current “hook” than I so far have) and a considered retrospective on the artistic contributions of the New York City Opera, with recommendations for recordings. I’ll keep you posted.
# # #
Footnotes
| ↑I | For those unable to score a ducat, the Met has even added a few days of free streaming video, which I’m sure makes the event seem better than it actually was, as always nowadays. |
|---|
